GiftCardMall vs Vanilla Gift Cards - Complete Comparison 2025
Detailed comparison between GiftCardMall and Vanilla gift cards. Compare fees, features, availability, and find which prepaid card is best for you.
GiftCardMall vs Vanilla Gift Cards: Which is Better?
Choosing between GiftCardMall and Vanilla gift cards can be confusing. Both are prepaid Visa and Mastercard options with similar features. This comprehensive comparison helps you decide which prepaid gift card is right for your needs.
Quick Feature Comparison
| Feature | GiftCardMall | Vanilla |
|---------|-------------|---------|
| Activation Fee | $2.95-$6.95 | $2.95-$6.95 |
| Monthly Fee | $2.50 after 12 months | $2.50 after 12 months |
| Registration Website | mygift.giftcardmall.com | vanillagift.com |
| Availability | Wide | Very Wide |
| Denominations | $25-$500 | $20-$500 |
| Customer Service | 24/7 phone | 24/7 phone |
Detailed Comparison
Fees
Both GiftCardMall and Vanilla gift cards have identical fee structures. Activation fees range from $2.95 to $6.95 depending on card value. Monthly maintenance fees of $2.50 begin after 12 months of inactivity.
Availability
Vanilla has a slight edge with more retail locations, especially at convenience stores and smaller retailers. GiftCardMall is readily available at major retailers like Walmart, Target, and CVS.
Online Registration
Both require registration for online purchases:
Our Recommendation
For most users: Either card works equally well. Choose whichever is more convenient to purchase at your local stores. If availability is your priority, Vanilla has a slight advantage.
Disclaimer: This website is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or connected to GiftCardMall, Giftcards.com, or Blackhawk Network. This is an independent informational resource.